Posted on Thu, Feb. 23, 2006--(Thanks Nina for this excellent link!!)
Why we need a robust vaccine market
Dr. Anthony S. Fauci - is director of the National Institute of Allergy and
Infectious Diseases at the National Institutes of Health in Bethesda, Md.
Seasonal influenza is generally not perceived as a major public health
threat. Yet it causes 36,000 deaths and 200,000 hospitalizations in the
United States each year, mostly among the elderly and other vulnerable
Although vaccination is the most important countermeasure against the flu,
fewer than one-third of Americans receive a flu shot each year. This bodes
poorly for our ability to prepare for a much more serious global influenza
If there were a crisis today similar to the 1918 outbreak of Spanish flu, in
which 50 million lives were lost worldwide, virtually everyone would want to
be vaccinated. But the infrastructure and vaccine-production capacity of
this nation and the world are not prepared for such demand.
One way to bridge this gap is to increase the production capacity for
seasonal flu vaccines. Then, if needed, these expanded manufacturing
facilities could readily switch over to produce a pandemic vaccine.
Progress in this direction is already occurring.
During the 2004-05 flu season, only three vaccine-makers were licensed to
distribute flu vaccine in the United States. This season, another
manufacturer received FDA approval, and additional suppliers are expressing
But growth in vaccine-production capacity must be matched with increased
consumer demand. During the 2004-05 flu season, 4.5 million vaccine doses
were not used and ultimately discarded. Companies forced to discard unused
vaccine and absorb a financial loss would be reluctant to increase
production capacity. Without a robust vaccine market, new and more efficient
ways to manufacture influenza vaccines may not be aggressively pursued.
Because seasonal influenza viruses mutate slightly from year to year,
vaccine must be reformulated for each flu season. Each year's vaccine
protects people from viruses that are slightly different from those of the
previous year, and adds protection to our existing immunity, accumulated
from previous exposures and immunizations.
In contrast, pandemic influenza occurs when humans are exposed to a highly
transmissible virus that is dramatically different from any virus they have
previously encountered. In that event, it will be crucial to produce and
distribute large quantities of vaccine matched to the circulating virus -
A pandemic could occur if one of the H5N1 avian flu viruses circulating in
Asia, Europe, the Middle East, and Africa acquired the ability to transmit
efficiently from person to person. The tendency of flu viruses to rapidly
mutate makes it difficult to predict which strain could trigger a global
pandemic. Nonetheless, public health officials, researchers, and industry
have decided to proceed with the development of vaccines based on currently
circulating bird flu strains. Such vaccines may not exactly match the viral
strain that ultimately triggers a pandemic, but can serve as prototypes
against a pandemic virus strain that may emerge later.
This effort serves two important purposes. As the H5N1 virus mutates, the
prototype vaccines may offer enough protection to prime the immune system
and reduce the severity of infection. This could buy precious time while a
vaccine that closely matches the pandemic strain was produced and
distributed. Producing prototype H5N1 vaccines also provides a trial run in
developing the infrastructure and production capacity to manufacture enough
vaccine should a worldwide pandemic ensue.
Once a safe and effective pandemic flu vaccine is developed, the challenge
remains to rapidly produce and distribute the product. But again, unless
consumer demand for seasonal flu vaccine increases significantly,
vaccine-makers may be hard-pressed to sustain the production capacity that
will ensure adequate supplies during a pandemic.
Yearly flu shots for most Americans would help create the infrastructure we
need to prepare for pandemics, with the added advantage of providing
immediate health benefits.
Contact Anthony S. Fauci at email@example.com.